So I'm torn. On the one hand they where delicious. On the other hand, it seemed like an overwhelming amount of icing… Thoughts?
by moldibread
48 Comments
pikapikapowwowwow
According to my wife, professional icing sous, that is the perfect amount.
I grew up in a half container of the cardboard tube icing household. Boy how did she show me the error of my ways.
Well done, recipie pls.
GlitteringRecord4383
Maybe a bit much, but it’s not crazy.
Prize_Imagination439
No. Gotta have all that extra to cover the sides when you pull them out
ambienoise
It could use more
synthscoreslut91
sidc42
You can NEVER have too much icing. Weirdos who don’t like it can scrape it off.
But that’s about what mine look like as long as you have extra for dipping.
I make mine with heavy cream and cream cheese so it has the extra fluffy quality too.
crazyuncleeddie
r/brandnewsentence IMO, there can never be enough.
U_Broke_I_Fix
Did someone imply it was too much? Disown them.
Shot-Statistician-89
I can still see a cinnamon roll so it’s not enough
MrNin69
I feel like it’s too much. A good cinnaroll will already be very moist. With that much icing, if warmed it’ll be nearly soggy.
Poinsettia917
Yes. Those are very bad for you. Send them here. We will take the bullet for you!
SalGalMo
I’ll taste test them for you and let you know 🙋
Poly_Olly_Oxen_Free
It’s more than I’d like, but then, I don’t have to eat it all. I don’t have much of a sweet tooth, in full honesty, so I’d take half of one on those, scrape half the icing off, and walk away smiling.
wannawinawiinebago
First picture: not even close
Second picture: 😱
My teeth hurt just looking at it.
marbotty
It appears I’m in the minority that thinks photo 1 is the perfect amount
Sad-Celebration-411
International_Film_1
JFC, those look good . Thats what my pants looking like right now
dustydigger
Is this a trick question?
pahuili
Looks like the rolls my mom used to make growing up. So they look perfect to me 😉
dromCase
Nope, they’re perfect.
ILoveBassetHounds_
NO!
BattledroidE
Well yes, but actually no.
LabBitch
I hate being diabetic…
Lavmaemor
I cannot weigh in until I’ve eaten half the pan, sorry
alfnyc
Available_Username_2
Are they good without icing? Then doesn’t matter how much icing, it’s subjective.
Are they not good without icing? Then doesn’t matter how much icing, it makes them better.
BootlegDouglas
This is a weirdly good visual example of how much context matters. All together in the pan, it immediately looks like too much frosting. The one by itself looks absolutely perfect (like “platonic ideal of a cinnamon roll” perfect, good job, damn).
Since you (probably) eat one at a time, it’s the perfect amount of frosting.
morcoire
No
Zealousideal-Ear1036
Nah
multibrow
Any icing is too much for me, but hey it’s your baking not mine! Plus they look good.
jake_8909
That’s fantastic, gimme 14 of em right now.
PretendCake8222
Can one put too much icing on a cinnamon bun? Asking for a friend
SagebrushID
I just pulled a batch out of the oven 1 minute ago. Will be dousing them with frosting in about 10 minutes. I hope I made enough frosting to make them look as good as yours!
BoxBird
This is the correct amount of icing 😂
TatiIsAPunk
Nope 😍
Li54
No. Should be swimming in it
salpn
If there’s too much icing on these buns for you, please send them my way 🙏!
Ornery-Function-6721
Looks so yummy
Yourmom4736251
No
Nibblefritz
Pretty sure this needs an NSFW tag because that’s just making me think of all the dirty things I’d do with those rolls.
Ihibri
It’s impossible to overdo the icing!
Outrageous_Border688
Perfect amount of icing. They look amazing!
Dogmoto2labs
I can see the rolls, so I would say no, not overdone.
fuzzius_navus
I prefer them sans frosting – those buns looked great.
However, a thin coating of cream cheese frosting is a treat u appreciate.
BGRdoc
mtn-ldy
stlcards2011
Like the words you are using make sense to me, but not in the way you used them. Is it possible to “overdo the icing?” Ever?
48 Comments
According to my wife, professional icing sous, that is the perfect amount.
I grew up in a half container of the cardboard tube icing household. Boy how did she show me the error of my ways.
Well done, recipie pls.
Maybe a bit much, but it’s not crazy.
No. Gotta have all that extra to cover the sides when you pull them out
It could use more
You can NEVER have too much icing. Weirdos who don’t like it can scrape it off.
But that’s about what mine look like as long as you have extra for dipping.
I make mine with heavy cream and cream cheese so it has the extra fluffy quality too.
r/brandnewsentence IMO, there can never be enough.
Did someone imply it was too much? Disown them.
I can still see a cinnamon roll so it’s not enough
I feel like it’s too much. A good cinnaroll will already be very moist. With that much icing, if warmed it’ll be nearly soggy.
Yes. Those are very bad for you. Send them here. We will take the bullet for you!
I’ll taste test them for you and let you know 🙋
It’s more than I’d like, but then, I don’t have to eat it all. I don’t have much of a sweet tooth, in full honesty, so I’d take half of one on those, scrape half the icing off, and walk away smiling.
First picture: not even close
Second picture: 😱
My teeth hurt just looking at it.
It appears I’m in the minority that thinks photo 1 is the perfect amount
JFC, those look good . Thats what my pants looking like right now
Is this a trick question?
Looks like the rolls my mom used to make growing up. So they look perfect to me 😉
Nope, they’re perfect.
NO!
Well yes, but actually no.
I hate being diabetic…
I cannot weigh in until I’ve eaten half the pan, sorry
Are they good without icing? Then doesn’t matter how much icing, it’s subjective.
Are they not good without icing? Then doesn’t matter how much icing, it makes them better.
This is a weirdly good visual example of how much context matters. All together in the pan, it immediately looks like too much frosting. The one by itself looks absolutely perfect (like “platonic ideal of a cinnamon roll” perfect, good job, damn).
Since you (probably) eat one at a time, it’s the perfect amount of frosting.
No
Nah
Any icing is too much for me, but hey it’s your baking not mine! Plus they look good.
That’s fantastic, gimme 14 of em right now.
Can one put too much icing on a cinnamon bun? Asking for a friend
I just pulled a batch out of the oven 1 minute ago. Will be dousing them with frosting in about 10 minutes. I hope I made enough frosting to make them look as good as yours!
This is the correct amount of icing 😂
Nope 😍
No. Should be swimming in it
If there’s too much icing on these buns for you, please send them my way 🙏!
Looks so yummy
No
Pretty sure this needs an NSFW tag because that’s just making me think of all the dirty things I’d do with those rolls.
It’s impossible to overdo the icing!
Perfect amount of icing. They look amazing!
I can see the rolls, so I would say no, not overdone.
I prefer them sans frosting – those buns looked great.
However, a thin coating of cream cheese frosting is a treat u appreciate.
Like the words you are using make sense to me, but not in the way you used them. Is it possible to “overdo the icing?” Ever?
Can i have one